| On the Mockney Prat | Paul 2008-10-15 09:49:00 UTC |
We love celebrity chefs here at Kamikaze Cookery. No, really, we do. I’m a particular fan of Nigella Lawson, although not, admittedly, for any reason relating to her food. All of us, to a greater or lesser extent, have a (sometimes grudging) respect for Heston Blumental. Naturally, Hugh is the only one crazy enough to have actually tried to cook one of his recipes. (I believe it took seventeen hours start to finish. Maybe he’ll tell you about it some time.) And therein lies the rub. Heston tells you to take twenty kilos of tomatoes and peel them. This is easy for him. He’s got a laboratory and a team of highly trained staff to do the peeling for him, so he can swan in at the last minute, do something magical with an ultrasound gun, and take all the credit. An average person, we feel, would have given up on about tomato #3 and sent out for pizza instead. It might be easier if the books told you how to peel tomatoes (soak them in hot water so that the skins swell, then they’re much easier to take off), but they don’t do that, either. You’re supposed to guess. And then there’s the language used in the recipes themselves. What does it mean when it tells you to sweat the carrots? Isn’t `sweat’ an intransitive verb? Why doesn’t anybody tell us this stuff? (I have a mental image now of a novice cook reading a book and then trying to force carrots out through his own pores. It’s not pretty.) Most celebrity chefs started off as chefs. They’ve had years of training and they’ve forgotten what it’s like to walk into a kitchen and wonder which one of these things is the fishknife, or which end of the peeler you hold, or whether it’s a five-second or a ten-second rule for dropping things on the floor. Since cooking is easy for them, it must be easy for us, so they don’t bother to explain things. I had the same problems with my maths lecturers at university, but that’s a subject for a whole different blog. And everyone secretly knows this. We buy these glossy recipe books, ooh and aah over the luscious pictures for a few minutes, and then display them proudly on our bookshelves unused. They’re like that copy of A Brief history of Time or the complete works of Shakespeare: certificates displaying membership of the petit-bourgeoisie, not practical documents. At Kamikaze Cookery, we like to cook stuff. We feel that recipe books are no help. Such a bold assertion desires proof! Fortunately, we have a science-based cookery show. Now we have an observational hypothesis and it’s time to test it. In this week’s episode, surprising almost exactly no one, we take on Jamie Oliver. As I discussed recently, Jamie’s back in the news of late, and while he’s being slightly cooler than he used to be, he’s still an arrogant little mockney prat. It has to be said, though, that he makes some good food and he wants to share it with the nation’s children. A noble goal, perhaps, but I’m fairly sure there are better ways to go about it than a reality television show. We took a normal person, the sort who might buy one of these sleb-chef cookbooks or get one as a present from a well-meaning relative, and set out to discover whether it was possible to extract the food from the equation while leaving behind the rampaging irritance that Jamie smears over everything he does. Along the way we read anecdotes about Jamie’s “housekeeper”, discovered interesting alternate spellings of simple words, and learned about the science behind pasta dough, which we cover in the episode. We’ve got more about dough coming up in a later video, when we cover a different celebrity chef. We found out which ingredients you can buy in a shop and which ones you have to travel to Italy for. We improvised kitchen implements and learned why pasta comes in packets. And at the end, we sat down and had dinner, and after all that, it was quite nice. Isn’t that the point? | |
| Hugh | 2008-10-15 10:44:56 UTC I feel I should defend Heston here – he does, in fact, tell you how to peel the tomatoes. And he’s one of the few cooks whose ingredient lists I will follow without fail – because he’s tested them a lot more than I have time, equipment, or honourary doctorates to do. And unlike any other celebrity chef I’ve tried recipes from (although I believe that Thomas Keller has a similar success rate), when you’ve spent the time on his recipes, they really are absolutely stunning. We’re hopefully going to do a Normal Person Vs Heston at some point in the future – look out for it! | |
| Suzi | 2008-10-15 11:43:16 UTC I have to admit that I have tried two Jamie Oliver recipies and been extreemly impressed with the outcome. In fact one of them included a sauce that when I tasted, I felt like leaving off the dish but I relented and it tasted perfect alongside the meat. I’ll be interested to see the 2nd episode! | |
| pajh | 2008-10-15 12:57:41 UTC Suzi: I liked the recipe. I’ve since adapted it myself, and now it only takes two hours, and it tastes better. Jamie’s not a bad cook—-I’ve never denied that. It’s his personality I have issues with. The episode is now up—-you can see for yourself. | |
| Amanda | 2008-10-15 16:02:48 UTC For me, cookbooks are basically porn.* I like to leer at them, flick through their glossy pages and set my imagination racing. Generally they’re my inspiration, but I agree that I would rarely actually cook from one. The two most useful cookery books I own are Pru Leith’s Cookery Bible and a giant reader’s digest encyclopaedia of food. And these are only ever used as reference tools. Not sure how to prepare Okra? How long to pan fry a duck breast if you remove the skin? If Prue doesn’t know, then the encyclopaedia does. Both are also full of excellent technical knowledge. Generally though, most actual cooking is a result of confidence. Something the mockney one did allude to on his show last night – teach someone the pan skills required to cook an omlette, and they’ll be less frightened to put a piece of meat in there next time… That kind of thing. It’s teaching that confidence that’s the problem, and I think most of the celeb cook books aren’t the crutch most people think they are – instead, they’re much more likely to just overwhelm and scare people off… It’s not something there’s an easy answer to unfortunately. (I believe Nigella Lawson’s Feast may qualify as *actual porn) | |
| Dougal Stanton | 2008-10-15 22:09:34 UTC I’m going to defend Nigella Lawson here, because she’s not a “proper cook”. She’s a journalist. And that kind of shows when you do her recipes. My girlfriend and I have been cooking the entirety of Nigella Express this year. We’re a wee bit behind schedule but we’re optimistic that it will all fall into place. And along the way we have been very surprised at how easy most of the recipes are. Tell you what though, I wouldn’t have tried this challenge with Feast. That’s a beast of a book and no mistake! | |
| Louise Dennis | 2008-10-16 11:47:49 UTC The few Jamie Oliver recipes I tried were rather bland and disappointing – I eventually gave the book to Oxfam. I’ve tried two Nigella Lawson recipes, I think. One was fine and could be cooked on a camping stove (which was an advantage since we were in one of our periodic no kitchen phases). The other had bizarrely incorrect quantities – a vast sea of lentils, IIRC, which seemed extremely careless for a professionally produced cook book, or at least, I thought the recipes were all tried out by another person just to check that kind of thing. I’m not sure what happened to that cookbook, it didn’t contain many recipes that inspired me to try them out at all so it may well have ended up in Oxfam too. Most of my recipe books do explain how to peel a tomato. Well they tell you to put them in hot water first – they don’t generally say why. It is true though that I rely less on actual recipes as I cook more. | |
| Hugh | 2008-10-16 14:49:28 UTC @Louise – Your experience of Jamie Oliver recipes pretty much perfectly fits how we found this one, actually – well-explained, simple, really boring to eat. I must admit, I don’t know why putting tomatoes in hot water works, either. Hmm. goes to find On Food And Cooking… @Amanda – the omlette point is really good, actually. I wonder if Jamie isn’t far better and more use as a teacher and advocate than he is as a cook… You recommend the Leith’s Cookery Bible? I was thinking of buying a Great Big Tome of some kind – either that or Larousse Gastronomique. About Nigella – well, I don’t want to spoiler for later in the series, but “erratic” seems to describe her writing down to a T. It’s interesting – virtually everyone has some experience of her work, and just about none of them agree. Personally, I recall a recipe she wrote for creme brulee which was Just Plain Wrong as far as I could tell – she advised heating at one stage for 10 minutes, which would have turned the entire thing into scrambled eggs. On the other hand, I’ve also heard people raving about her. I’m really surprised that you’ve managed to cook every single one of the recipes in her book, on that basis, Dougal. Really impressive! It appears she’s not even consistent in being inconsistent… (I agree, she also writes really, really well – her and Nigel Slater are amongst the best writers on food out there.) | |
| Louise Dennis | 2008-10-16 17:19:48 UTC I once saw Nigella and Nigel Slater cooking together. I’m surprised they don’t do it more often since she’s all about “sexy mum” and he’s all about how food is sexy and reminds him of childhood and his mum. | |
| Manannan | 2008-10-23 16:08:02 UTC Does Thomas Keller’s recipe book have a recipe for scrambled egg? I had breakfast at the Bouchon in Vegas a couple of years ago. I asked for poached egg. The waiter said poached egg was off: the egg poaching machine was broken (!). So I tried scrambled egg – which was delivered to my table in about five minutes. Oh dear. Not long enough. It was basically mashed up fried egg, which I quite like, and is fine if you’ve ordered it in from a short order chef in a diner, but is appalling, bearing in mind that Keller has a stellar reputation for French food. It’s a pity, because proper scrambled egg is dead easy, and incredibly delicious, and the only hard-to-find ingredient is time. | |
| Hugh | 2008-10-23 16:14:51 UTC Hmm – I honestly don’t know. I’ve not got the French Laundry cookbook yet – but I’ll check once I have. I AM surprised that any Keller restaurant served something less than stellar, though. Bad luck! | |
| ColeEULA30 | 2011-03-22 23:02:54 UTC Houses and cars are expensive and not everybody is able to buy it. However, business loans are created to support different people in such hard situations. | |
| BurgessKeisha21 | 2012-01-02 00:04:06 UTC When you’re in not good state and have no cash to get out from that point, you will have to take the credit loans. Just because it will help you emphatically. I take short term loan every single year and feel myself great because of that. | |
Latest Blog Entries
Fascinating stuff - the science of the stall
Tips for surviving the Four Hour Body as a foodie - recipes and tips
Khymos is going through Srs Fd Science - today, stocks
Your Chocolate Is Made By Enslaved Kids
Pressure Extraction - My First Attempts
Pressure, extraction, and marinades
Latest Comments
Comments will return once our spammer plague slows
-
-
-
-
-
-
Latest KKC Infodumps
What's the best blue electric kettle on the market?
What's the best organic instant coffee brand?
Should you buy a steel cafetiere? Actually, yes.
What are ESE coffee pods, and do they compare to a real espresso?
How -and Why - to find Fair Trade chocolate brands
What you need to know about fair trade bananas
What you need to know about Shade-Grown Coffee